Donald Trump fears Americans in the streets more than anything else. Millions of them, day after day, peaceful and ungovernable. It is one of the only things that can threaten his continued hold on power and the hardest to neutralize.
So he’s trying to criminalize it before it happens.
Last week, the producer of Amanpour and Co. reached out about my column “Political Violence Is Here to Stay.” One of her questions was simple: should we be worried about the recent rise in left-wing violence?
It’s the right question, but not in the way most people think. Most people are worried that two sides arming up can lead to civil war. What I worry about is something more immediate: that the small recent rise in left-wing violence will be weaponized to justify mass repression.
Last week I argued that political violence is here to stay, possibly for decades. That’s because none of the underlying conditions will be easy to change - democratic reform, gun control, and social media regulation are not coming quickly.
That’s the surface story. Beneath it runs a second, more dangerous, story. As violence continues, MAGA will try to use every act of left-wing violence, however isolated, to justify suppressing any opposition.
What the Numbers Actually Show
Here are the facts that make that second story so alarming.
Right-wing extremist violence has been responsible for approximately 75% to 80% of U.S. domestic terrorism deaths since 2001. Charleston. Pittsburgh. El Paso. Buffalo. Most of those attacks were related to America’s white supremacy movement, with a smattering of anti-federal government attacks in between. For almost two decades, that has been America’s real domestic terrorism problem. It’s been almost all on the right, not on the left.
Then, in 2025, the numbers shifted.
2025 marks the first time in more than 30 years that far left terrorist attacks outnumbered those from the far right and a big reason for this is that far right attacks declined in 2025. But MAGA is presenting these attacks as evidence that America now has a left-wing terrorist problem.
The numbers tell a very different story.
In the past decade, right-wing attacks have killed ten times as many people as left-wing attacks (112 versus 13). And within 48 hours of Charlie Kirk’s assassination, the Department of Justice removed its own study from its website - a study whose very first paragraph stated that far-right extremists have committed “far more ideologically motivated homicides” than any other group.
The far-left and the far-right in this country are not equivalent. The far left has no organized infrastructure for seizing power. No militia movement. No paramilitary networks. No coordinated plan. What it has is a collection of angry, isolated individuals who are dangerous, but a categorically different threat from the organized right-wing groups that spent years preparing for armed conflict against minorities and the federal government.
Right-wing violence is declining in part because the far-right now controls all the levers of power - they’ve won the whole kit and caboodle. But they are organized in a way that would allow them to return if they again feel threatened.
When someone tells you America has a left-wing violence problem, ask them why they are not talking about the right. They will probably say that there is no problem on the right. But that’s simply not true.
The Infrastructure for Repression Has Already Been Built
Trump is not just changing the narrative about who is a terrorist, he’s building the infrastructure to arrest those he includes in this category. Here’s how he’s doing it.
Following the assassination of Charlie Kirk, Trump signed National Security Presidential Memorandum 7 - a presidential directive that for the first time appears to authorize law enforcement measures against Americans based not on whether they are planning to commit violence but on their political or ideological beliefs. It identifies anti-Americanism, anti-capitalism, and anti-Christianity as potential terrorism red flags - language so broad that rights groups warn it risks sweeping in protest movements and critics of the administration. Stephen Miller stated that merely calling the administration “authoritarian” - as Gavin Newsom did - “incites violence and terrorism.” The Joint Terrorism Task Force can now investigate Americans for their beliefs rather than their actions. Civil liberties lawyers say the closest analogies are Nixon and the Red Scare.
The means to arrest people is already up and running. ICE - effectively a private police force answerable only to Trump - has been deployed to domestic protests. Detention facilities capable of holding large numbers of people have been built or expanded. Taken individually, each move can be explained away. Taken together, they form a system designed to have everything ready should Americans take to the streets to protest a contested or suspended an election.
That is the scenario Trump is building towards.
What Orban Learned and What Trump Hasn’t. Yet.
History suggests that massive numbers of voters or protesters are the one thing authoritarians can’t neutralize. Viktor Orbán discovered this in Hungary. The vote against him was so enormous that he was powerless to stop it. Trump can arrest dozens of citizens, but he can’t arrest millions. He can call protesters “terrorists”, but he can’t make that label stick when the protester is your neighbor, your doctor, your kid’s teacher, half the country standing in the street.
Trump may have ICE. He may have detention centers. He may have the legal framework to call you a terrorist for disagreeing with him. But Americans have the numbers. And if they choose to use them - peacefully, persistently, and in overwhelming force - no executive order can make that disappear.
Orbán learned it the hard way. So will Trump, if Americans decide to show up.
If you think more people should read this, please restack it. It helps get the message out. And if you’re new to Here Be Dragons, subscribe below.
Want to understand what’s really happening beneath the political surface?
Here Be Dragons uses research on power, political instability, and democratic decline to make sense of what’s happening now.



Thank you Barbara, I've admired your work since I first heard you on Ezra Klein some years ago now. And now it seems your essays attract right-wing antidemocrats and bots. Congratulations, I take it that means you're doing the right thing.
Would love to hear your take on the report out this week from CBC that foreign actors including the US and Russia have been paying influencers to encourage separatism movement in Alberta.
Anyway, keep it up and see you out there in the streets.
The plan to criminalize dissent began long before NSPM-7. It originated with the Heritage Foundation's Project Esther, published in late 2024, which equated all criticism of Israel with terrorism.
https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Project%20Esther.pdf
The federal government used the framework outlined in Project Esther's to deport college students, professors, and attack academic freedom, by withholding government funding from colleges and universities to silence not just legitimate criticism of Israel, its brutal occupation, and ongoing genocide in Gaza, but also Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion programs, and even censor course curricula.
NSPM-7 was modeled after Project Esther. Both employ the same bad faith logic: Project Esther equates criticism of Israel as support for terrorism; NSPM-7 does this by declaring "gender ideology, anti-Americanism, anti-capitalism, or anti-Christianity" to be signs of extremism. If you read both documents side by side, it's easy to see NSPM-7 is a rewritten version of Project Esther aimed at criminalizing dissent in the U.S. Recall how Renee Good and Alex Pretti were immediately smeared as terrorists after being murdered by ICE in Minneapolis: that's from the Project Esther/NSPM-7 playbook for criminalizing dissent.
The recent indictment of the SPLC is also straight out of Project Esther, which advocates targeting funding of nonprofits and NGOs that criticize Israel, or in the case of NSPM-7, challenge MAGA's agenda of white Christian supremacy. Ironically, the SPLC warned that one of Project Esther's real goals was to criminalize protest, in its written comments to the Senate Judiciary Committee, just over one year before the DOJ used the Project Esther framework to indict the SPLC. The SPLC was targeted for repression for the same reasons as Harvard and Columbia: by bullying the top universities and civil rights nonprofits, the aim is to intimidate smaller universities and nonprofits to self-censor and acquiesce to fascism.
https://www.splcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/statement-senate-judiciary-committee-antisemitism-.pdf