Discussion about this post

User's avatar
EFK's avatar

Thank you Barbara, I've admired your work since I first heard you on Ezra Klein some years ago now. And now it seems your essays attract right-wing antidemocrats and bots. Congratulations, I take it that means you're doing the right thing.

Would love to hear your take on the report out this week from CBC that foreign actors including the US and Russia have been paying influencers to encourage separatism movement in Alberta.

Anyway, keep it up and see you out there in the streets.

Dawson's avatar

The plan to criminalize dissent began long before NSPM-7. It originated with the Heritage Foundation's Project Esther, published in late 2024, which equated all criticism of Israel with terrorism.

https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Project%20Esther.pdf

The federal government used the framework outlined in Project Esther's to deport college students, professors, and attack academic freedom, by withholding government funding from colleges and universities to silence not just legitimate criticism of Israel, its brutal occupation, and ongoing genocide in Gaza, but also Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion programs, and even censor course curricula.

NSPM-7 was modeled after Project Esther. Both employ the same bad faith logic: Project Esther equates criticism of Israel as support for terrorism; NSPM-7 does this by declaring "gender ideology, anti-Americanism, anti-capitalism, or anti-Christianity" to be signs of extremism. If you read both documents side by side, it's easy to see NSPM-7 is a rewritten version of Project Esther aimed at criminalizing dissent in the U.S. Recall how Renee Good and Alex Pretti were immediately smeared as terrorists after being murdered by ICE in Minneapolis: that's from the Project Esther/NSPM-7 playbook for criminalizing dissent.

The recent indictment of the SPLC is also straight out of Project Esther, which advocates targeting funding of nonprofits and NGOs that criticize Israel, or in the case of NSPM-7, challenge MAGA's agenda of white Christian supremacy. Ironically, the SPLC warned that one of Project Esther's real goals was to criminalize protest, in its written comments to the Senate Judiciary Committee, just over one year before the DOJ used the Project Esther framework to indict the SPLC. The SPLC was targeted for repression for the same reasons as Harvard and Columbia: by bullying the top universities and civil rights nonprofits, the aim is to intimidate smaller universities and nonprofits to self-censor and acquiesce to fascism.

https://www.splcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/statement-senate-judiciary-committee-antisemitism-.pdf

13 more comments...

Ready for more?